Ghost jobs tracker
Ghost jobs: how to spot listings that may not lead to a hire
We don't survey anyone. We watch employers' own job boards and report what the listings do: how long they stay up, whether they come back under a new ID, and whether the board is still active.
32.4%
of open US listings at active employers were posted more than 90 days ago.
Active = 3+ new roles in the last 30 days (206,894 listings). Across all employers: 50.6%; over a year old: 11.3% at active employers, 32.6% overall.
37.7%
of open US postings first seen since Oct 5 re-open a role with the same title and location that closed in the previous 180 days.
31,954 of 84,848 postings. Staffing firms, aggregators and capped boards are left out.
78,008
open listings sit on 3,974 job boards that have posted nothing new in 30 days.
US listings. A quiet board can still be hiring for the roles it already has open.
Cite this
Source: HirQ analysis of public job boards, ghost-job signals on open US listings, as of Nov 20, 2026. hirq.ai/insightsFree to reuse with attribution and a link (CC BY 4.0).
What people mean by “ghost job”
A ghost job is a listing that is unlikely to lead to a hire: already filled, paused, or kept up to collect resumes. Estimates vary because definitions do. Greenhouse has put ghost posts at about 18–22% of postings on its platform in a given quarter, an Ashby analysis found 82% of jobs on its platform were filled, and an estimate based on government JOLTS data puts the figure near 30%.
HirQ doesn't survey anyone; we watch employers' own job boards.
Sources: CPA Practice Advisor, Ashby, Fox4 (Greenhouse).
The six signals we check
True age
How long the listing has been up on the employer's own board, using the original posting date when the board gives one. Most roles close within about three weeks.
Repeat re-posts
Whether the same title in the same location closed and reappeared under a new ID, and how many times in six months.
Dormant board
Whether the employer has posted anything new in the last 30 days, and how often roles on its board close.
Evergreen or talent-pool title
“General application”, “Talent community” and similar listings collect resumes rather than fill one opening. We label them as such.
No pay range detected
A missing range is a weak signal on its own, stronger in states whose laws generally require one in job ads.
Vague description
Very short descriptions, or no clear location or remote arrangement, make it harder to tell what the role is.
Ghost risk across open listings
HirQ's estimate for every open US job, with the reasons shown on each job page.
Ghost-risk level
309,592 open US listings scored.
- Low114K · 37%
- Medium86K · 28%
- High110K · 35%
Cite this
Source: HirQ analysis of public job boards, ghost-risk distribution of open US listings, as of Nov 20, 2026. hirq.ai/insightsFree to reuse with attribution and a link (CC BY 4.0).
High-risk share by job category
Largest categories, at least 200 open listings each.
- 80%
- 59%
- 55%
- 51%
- 40%
- 32%
- 30%
- 29%
Cite this
Source: HirQ analysis of public job boards, share of open US listings with high ghost risk, by category, as of Nov 20, 2026. hirq.ai/insightsFree to reuse with attribution and a link (CC BY 4.0).
Listings open 90+ days by sector
Share of open US listings with a known date posted more than 90 days ago.
- 83%
- 81%
- 64%
- 60%
- 55%
- 50%
- 48%
- 46%
Cite this
Source: HirQ analysis of public job boards, share of open US listings older than 90 days, by sector, as of Nov 20, 2026. hirq.ai/insightsFree to reuse with attribution and a link (CC BY 4.0).
Repost watch
Employers whose open roles most often re-open a role with the same title and location.
191 employers currently have at least 50 measured open roles with 20% or more re-posts. Names appear only after an employer meets the rule in two consecutive weekly snapshots and the list is reviewed. Until then, here is the same measure by sector.
- Healthcare Providers63%n 18,203
- Retail & E-commerce59%n 6,986
- Hospitality, Food & Travel48%n 2,348
- Real Estate & Construction47%n 3,834
- Government & Nonprofit45%n 2,578
- Education & EdTech44%n 2,603
- Fitness, Beauty & Wellness40%n 898
- Transportation & Logistics36%n 1,309
- Banking, Insurance & Finance35%n 1,559
- Manufacturing & Industrial34%n 6,859
Roles open the longest
Open roles with the oldest original posting dates, on boards that are still posting.
Listing open for a long time is common for continuous roles and does not by itself mean a role isn't real. General applications are left out; at most 3 roles per employer.
Law tracker
Status as reported; verify before relying.
| Where | Status |
|---|---|
| Ontario, Canada Employers with 25+ staff must say whether a posting is for an existing vacancy and update interviewed candidates within 45 days. | In force since Jan 1, 2026 |
| New York (S8877) Employers with 100+ staff and third-party job sites would state whether a vacancy exists and remove postings within two weeks of filling them. | Passed the legislature; awaiting signature |
| New Jersey (S2136) Disclose whether a real vacancy exists; remove the posting soon after it is filled. | Proposed |
| California (AB 1251) Similar vacancy disclosure and removal rules. | Proposed |
| US federal No federal rule specific to ghost postings. | No law |
Sources: Bloomberg Law, SHRM. This is not legal advice.
Check any job link
Paste a posting and see its true age, re-post history and the signals above.
See ghost risk and repost history on every job
Free members see age and re-post counts. Pro shows the risk level with its reasons, the listing history and the employer's follow-through.
Questions
Are ghost jobs illegal?
In most places, no. Ontario has required employers with 25 or more staff to say whether a posting is for an existing vacancy since Jan 1, 2026. New York's S8877 passed the legislature and was awaiting the governor's signature in the latest coverage, and bills are pending in New Jersey, California and Pennsylvania. There is no federal law. Status as reported; verify before relying on it.
Why do companies repost jobs?
Common reasons are high-volume roles that are always being filled (retail, care, drivers), a posting that expired on the job board, a refreshed description, or a role that was filled and opened again. A re-post on its own does not mean the role is not real.
Does an old listing mean it's fake?
No. Some roles are filled continuously and some searches take months. Age is one signal among several; HirQ combines it with re-posts, the employer's board activity and the description before showing a ghost-risk estimate.
How does HirQ calculate ghost risk?
Each open job gets points for age, repeat re-posts, evergreen wording, a stale or dormant board and missing details, with credit for a posted pay range and an active board. The total maps to low, medium or high, and the reasons are listed with the estimate. The full method is on the How it works page.
I'm an employer and the data is wrong: what can I do?
Use the contact form with the topic “data correction” and include the listing or company page. We reply within 5 business days and correct verified errors.
Methodology and corrections
HirQ's ghost-risk estimate and company labels are automated opinions based on what we observe on employers' public job boards: how long a listing has been open, whether it was re-listed, wording in the description, and how often roles on that board close. They are not statements about an employer's intent, and a high-risk listing can still be a real opening. Data is refreshed several times a day; figures are as of the date shown. Employers can request a review at the contact page.
Figures are recomputed hourly from HirQ's reads of public job boards since Oct 3, 2026. How we measure · Request a correction
Rankings are HirQ's analysis of postings on employers' public job boards, observed since Oct 3, 2026. Reposting and long-open listings are common for high-volume and continuous roles and do not by themselves mean a role isn't real. Employers can request a review at /contact (topic: data correction); we reply within 5 business days and correct verified errors.